A Hennepin County district judge overseeing the prosecution of four former officers charged in the May 25 killing of George Floyd has denied a prosecution request for a 48-hour seal on filings in the case.
Judge Peter Cahill announced the decision at an emergency hearing Thursday after a defense attorney moved Monday to file into evidence a video and transcript from Floyd’s arrest by Minneapolis police in May 2019 — a year before he died in custody on a south Minneapolis street corner.
Cahill said the video “shows what basically everybody already knows: George Floyd was arrested on a previous occasion.” He said he would not build in any additional time lag on the release of filings in the case, but added that he won’t allow audio, video or photos attached to future filings. That material, if it’s deemed public, will be available at the courthouse, however.
A media coalition, including the Star Tribune, opposed the prosecution motion and received the document as a party in an ongoing dispute over what documents are public in the case. The document and video at issue, submitted by lawyer Earl Gray, highlights similarities in Floyd’s behavior in 2019 to what was seen on video in his fatal 2020 encounter with police.
Cahill dispensed with the matter in a 25-minute hearing. He explained that an electronic lag exists between when a document is submitted through the court’s e-filing system and when it is accepted by a court clerk and becomes part of the official case record.
In this case, prosecutors saw Gray’s filing and objected before it became part of the record. Cahill said Gray held off on the formal filing of the document pending the Thursday court hearing.
The court did not seal a document, Cahill said.
The media coalition lawyer, Leita Walker, who appeared via telephone, said once a lawyer sends a document to the electronic system, “it’s presumptively public because it’s under consideration by the court.”
Given the global attention on this case, Walker said there already are “mountains of information and potential disinformation” that potential jurors already have seen.
The prosecutors sought to build a permanent, 48-hour lag into the process, giving them time to object to filings and keep them out of public view. Prosecutor Matthew Frank accused the defense of “e-mailing things” to the court “just to make them public.”
This practice, Frank argued, was likely to interfere with a fair trial.
Cahill, however, dismissed that criticism. “I do find that this was good faith on Mr. Gray’s part because I left the door open,” Cahill said of the possible admission at trial of the 2019 arrest.
The judge noted that he had closed the door on admitting evidence of an armed robbery in Texas involving Floyd. Had Gray’s filings included specifics of that case, that would have been in bad faith, Cahill said.
Cahill also said he viewed the 2019 arrest video as potentially helpful to the prosecution’s case. The document and video became publicly available immediately after the hearing. What wasn’t at issue Thursday was whether the earlier arrest video will be shown to the jury during trial. That ruling will come closer to or during the trial currently set to begin March 8.
According to Gray’s memo, he wants to show the video at trial because prosecutors have presented a “false narrative” by portraying Floyd as a “law-abiding citizen that was afraid for his life.”
In the video, as described by Gray, three police officers were working to get Floyd to respond to commands to show his hands, stop moving around and spit out something he had put in his mouth. Floyd cried out for his “mama” and told police, “Don’t shoot me, man.”
Gray represents Thomas Lane, who is charged with aiding and abetting murder and manslaughter. Former officers J. Alexander Kueng and Tou Thao face the same charges, while former officer Derek Chauvin, who knelt on Floyd’s neck, is charged with second-degree unintentional murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter.
All lawyers were present for Thursday’s hearing, but only Gray stopped briefly on his way out of the courthouse to speak to reporters and cameras waiting on the skyway level. The media session lasted only a couple of minutes before 10K Foundation activist Jonathan Mason became argumentative and cut off his answers to reporters’ questions.
Mason, who held up his cellphone and recorded the exchange, pressed Gray about alleged prior behavior by Chauvin. The lawyer responded that he doesn’t represent Chauvin.
As Gray turned to leave, Mason got up next to him and followed him out, continuing to press him, accusing him of “protecting a killer.” The two men were so close they appeared on the verge of exchanging blows.
Gray accused Mason of being under the influence of alcohol; Mason accused Gray of being “afraid” of him.
After the hearing, as half a dozen protesters walked through the Government Center shouting expletives targeting Chauvin, Hennepin County sheriff’s deputies arrested a man and confiscated out what appeared to be a black handgun. They also arrested a woman. It’s unknown what prompted the arrests.
Despite heavy security, it’s the second consecutive hearing on the case that ended in a potentially explosive confrontation of defense counsel. A woman was charged with damaging another lawyer’s truck after the Sept. 11 hearing as angry protesters followed and yelled “murderer” at two former police officers and their lawyers on the way out of the courthouse.
Mason told reporters he’s not done protesting. “Derek Chauvin will not be allowed to walk free,” he said.
In the brief hearing, Cahill didn’t hint at when he might rule on several other significant motions that were argued Sept. 11. They include motions to dismiss the charges against the former officers, to try them separately, and to change the venue of their trials because of pretrial publicity.
Hennepin County sheriff’s deputies handcuffed two protesters in the courthouse later in the afternoon. A group of about eight protesters walked around the skyway level of the courthouse a little before 3 p.m. Some yelled, “[Expletive] Derek Chauvin!”
An unidentified man who yelled, “Kill Derek Chauvin!” was handcuffed, searched and taken away after deputies apparently found a black handgun on him. Deputies also handcuffed protester Sara Marshall, 24, who was standing near the man but said she did not know him. She was released after being questioned for about 45 minutes.
“It was traumatizing,” said Marshall, who will not be allowed onto courthouse grounds for a year.
The Hennepin County Sheriff’s Office did not immediately have a statement on the matter.
Saff writer Chao Xiong contributed information to this report.
"case" - Google News
October 16, 2020 at 04:03AM
https://ift.tt/2Hcv3YU
Judge denies prosecution's request to seal on filings in George Floyd case for at least 48 hours - Minneapolis Star Tribune
"case" - Google News
https://ift.tt/37dicO5
https://ift.tt/2VTi5Ee
Bagikan Berita Ini
0 Response to "Judge denies prosecution's request to seal on filings in George Floyd case for at least 48 hours - Minneapolis Star Tribune"
Post a Comment